Right-wing militia members occupy federal building in rural Oregon
5 January 2016
On Saturday, approximately two dozen armed, right-wing militia members took control of an unoccupied visitors’ center at the Malheur National Wildlife Refuge, a federal nature preserve approximately 30 miles south of the city of Burns in sparsely populated Harney County, Oregon. The action is being carried out in protest against restrictions on government-controlled land.
The Malheur occupation began after a march by some 300 people in Burns to protest the reimprisonment of ranchers Dwight Hammond, 73, and his son Steven Hammond, 46, who were convicted in 2012 of setting fires on federal lands in 2001 and 2006.
Despite the protest and ongoing occupation, both Dwight and Steven Hammond voluntarily reported to prison Monday, while their lawyers sought clemency from President Obama. Suzie Hammond, Dwight Hammond’s wife, told Fox News that her family had no role in the occupation and she was not planning to visit the militiamen occupying Malheur.
The group, known as Citizens for Constitutional Freedom, is led by Ammon and Ryan Bundy, the sons of Nevada rancher Cliven Bundy. Speaking to the Oregonian Saturday night, Ammon Bundy said the group was “planning on staying here for years, absolutely.” He added, “This is not a decision we’ve made at the last minute.”
The Bundy family gained notoriety in 2014 after it rallied support among militia members in a standoff with the Bureau of Land Management (BLM) over grazing rights on federal property. The family successfully forced BLM agents to back down, an outcome that emboldened far-right elements throughout the country.
In an interview with CBS News on Monday, Ammon Bundy said that a “demand for redress” of grievances of ranchers intimidated by federal authorities had been sent to local, state and federal officials. The group has set a deadline of five days for a response, but has not indicated what it will do if it does not receive one.
“The wildlife refuge has been a tool that government has used for many years to take the land and resources away from the people,” Bundy said. He continued, “The people of this county are being abused and they're being prosecuted because they're not willing to sell to the federal government, and it's just one of those things that just cannot continue.”
The Hammonds were tried and convicted under a subsection of the Antiterrorism and Effective Death Penalty Act of 1996, which carries a mandatory minimum five-year prison sentence for setting fire to federal property. During initial sentencing in 2012, US District Judge Michael R. Hogan rejected the mandatory sentence as unfair and instead sentenced the elder Hammond to three months and his son to one year and one month. The two ranchers were also ordered to pay some $400,000 in damages to the federal government. Both men served their sentences and were released.
In the meantime, Justice Department attorneys appealed the sentences as a violation of the mandatory minimum stipulated by the law. In 2014, a three-judge panel of the 9th US Circuit Court of Appeals overturned the lesser sentences and ordered that the Hammonds be re-sentenced and finish out the minimum prison terms.
In a previous confrontation at Malheur in 1994, Dwight and Steven Hammond were arrested by armed federal agents after they blocked a work crew that was seeking to erect a fence to keep the Hammonds’ cattle from grazing on government property after their grazing rights were revoked.
While the occupation by the Citizens for Constitutional Freedom has so far attracted a very limited number of people, the group has been given substantial media coverage. Right-wing militia groups enjoy a sympathetic ear from sections of the Republican Party and the military. For all their attempts to portray themselves as common citizens, it is clear that they are working with experienced political forces.
During the standoff in 2014, which was covered extensively by Fox News, the Bundys received support from a number of Republican politicians, including Senators Ted Cruz and Rand Paul, both now seeking their party’s nomination for president. The Bundy family, in turn, has donated money to the campaigns of both Rand Paul and his father Ron Paul.
Ammon Bundy and the other militia members may couch their appeals in populist language, but they have a definite right-wing political agenda and see the Malheur occupation as an event that can strengthen and rally far-right forces.
In this context, it is notable that the response of the Obama administration and state law enforcement agencies is vastly different from what normally occurs when there are popular protests reflecting mass grievances, particularly over incidents of police violence.
The first official response from the White House to the occupation came on Monday and was decidedly low-key. White House Press Secretary Josh Earnest acknowledged that President Obama was aware of the situation and that the FBI was monitoring the situation and providing aid to local authorities, but insisted that the seizure of federal property remained a “local matter.”
Harney County Sheriff Dave Ward released a statement Saturday urging residents to stay away from the area and maintain a “peaceful and united front.” He also warned that the group had “alternative motives to attempt to overthrow the county and federal government in hopes to spark a movement across the United States.”
There is a palpable sense that federal and local officials are wary of generating any broader sympathy for the militiamen. The FBI released a statement indicating that it was working with the Harney County Sheriff’s Office and Oregon State Police to “bring a peaceful resolution to the situation.”
Bloody assaults by federal agents on Ruby Ridge in northern Idaho in 1992 and the Branch Davidian compound in Waco, Texas in 1993 fueled the growth of the right-wing militia movements throughout the US, culminating in the 1995 Oklahoma City bombing by Timothy McVeigh, which killed 168 people and wounded more than 680 others.
According to the Southern Poverty Law Center, the anti-government militia movement has experienced a notable growth in the last year, expanding from 202 to 276 known active organizations. With the onset of the economic crisis in 2008 and the election of Obama, the first African American president, the number of militia groups grew dramatically from 42 to a peak of 334 in 2011.
The Socialist Equality Party opposes the use of federal forces against these groups, not because socialists sympathize with their political demands, but because long experience has demonstrated that repressive measures used against the right are employed with redoubled force against the left.
Nevertheless, the proliferation of such right-wing groupings and their ability, however limited, to appeal to a broader audience should be taken as a warning. To the extent that far-right tendencies can cast themselves as victims of government violence, they do so under conditions where much broader popular protests are severely limited and suppressed and genuine grievances cannot find a progressive outlet within the political or media establishment.
The answer to the threat posed by right-wing forces such as those occupying Malheur does not lie in the mobilization of the forces of the state, but in the development of an international movement of the working class fighting for social equality in a struggle against the capitalist system.